Sometimes private blockchains suit a company’s needs and sometimes public ones do. Orbs offers another alternative, founder Tal Kol said.
Mr. Kol has spent his entire career as a tech entrepreneur. In 2012 he co-founded the mobile commerce platform Appixia which was sold to Wix. He spent the next few years running engineering at Wix and then Kik Interactive before cofounding Orbs late in 2017.
“What we saw was traditional companies were
trying to create dApps,” Mr. Kol said. “But as time progressed the problem with
dApps was their infrastructure was immature. Ethereum was immature, slow.
“This wasn’t an infrastructure problem but a
Some of the issues are philosophical, Mr. Kol
explained. The decentralized model for dApps cancels out standard for-profit
business models. Then there are the structural ones common to a sector’s early
days such as scaling problems, but those are starting to be solved. So are
other issues through trial and error, leaving the challenge of providing public
blockchains to the enterprise.
One big obstacle is simple bandwidth, Mr. Kol
said. While in theory you could launch an Uber-style service on some
blockchains, all it would take is for Crypto Kitties to launch on the same
network and your service suddenly stinks.
Then there’s the problem of how some companies
address bugs. What if the network votes to roll back the history to before the
“That may work for dApps, but for a traditional
company like Uber, no,” Mr. Kol said.
The key is isolation, he said. Keep every app
isolated from the others through their own virtual chains. That solves
resource, scaling and governing issues. You share the same infrastructure and
the power of validators from around the world.
“It’s a well-known concept,” Mr. Kol said. “We
applied it to blockchain technology and it worked remarkably well. It had the
security and decentralization of a network but provided an isolated
Orbs commits to a guaranteed transaction
throughput, so if you pay for, say, 100 TPS you will always get that. You also
control your governance, so if a bug appears in a different app you maintain
your own batch and don’t need network approval to rectify any problems.
What are the best applications for Orbs in
today’s marketplace? That’s an interesting question, Mr. Kol said. Does
blockchain provide value to a company like Uber? That’s hard to say and Uber
likely has no idea of where it fits in, he suggested. The value lies in helping
to establish new trust levels with users.
Mr. Kol recently was in New York and took a
popular ride sharing service to a meeting across town. The algorithm lied in
its estimate of how long the ride would take and that made him late for the
meeting. Was it intentional? Did they do that to keep him from using another
service, cabs or the subway? If that company operated on blockchain technology
you could audit it for yourself and learn the true answer.
Do the Facebooks of the world “take your data
“Business will come to see the best way to reach this level of trust is to rely on technology to provide it,” Mr. Kol said.
And look to the grey when arguing the merits of
public versus private blockchains, Mr. Kol said.
“Purely private blockchains are not innovative,
there is nothing new there which we didn’t have 40 years ago.”
Mix the best of public and private blockchains
and you’re on to something, Mr. Kol said. Have block producers and validators,
where the app controls the producers and the network controls the validators.
“You need both to work,” he explained.
The reputation of public blockchains suffer from
misconceptions, Mr. Kol said. Not all data becomes public and such tools as
zero knowledge encryption provide adequate protection.
“The fears of business and governments are
irrational,” Mr. Kol said.
Yet for all the talk about red herring security
issues, there is one vulnerability not getting nearly enough attention in the
industry and that is front running, where, if people know the node order they
can choose the order of the transactions on a decentralized exchange to enjoy
While there is no one perfect solution, an
effective tactic could be to encrypt all transactions when they are sent to
miners so they don’t know what is underneath. After the consensus round use
threshold encryption to open it.
“The miner commits to the order before they see
what is transacted inside,” Mr. Kol said.
The problem with consensus is the tradeoff
between security and speed, Mr. Kol said. Decentralized security wants lots of
nodes but that slows things down. What’s the solution?
With every consensus opportunity randomly choose
21 node committees from every 1,000-node group. Each time choose a different
1,000-node group and differently-situated nodes within that group.
“There are always 21 or 22 talking together. It’s just as decentralized,” Mr. Kol said.
This article contains new, firsthand information uncovered by its reporter(s). This includes directly interviewing sources and research / analysis of primary source documents.
As a news piece, this article cites verifiable, third-party sources which have all been thoroughly fact-checked and deemed credible by the Newsroom in accordance with the Civil Constitution.
This Newsmaker has been deemed by this Newsroom as having a specialized knowledge of the subject covered in this article.